​Tickets are non-refundable. In the event you cannot make the show you may use them for another show for up to one year depending on show availability. Email BrewsterTheaterInfo@gmail.com within 10 days after the show date to establish a future credit.


Due to a substantial rent increase, our ticket prices have increased in 2025. 

Brewster Theater Company is Sponsored By

Brewster Theater Company is located at The Theater at Drew Methodist Church at 28 Gleneida Avenue in Carmel, NY. We have plenty of parking in the rear of the building. 

Audience Volunteer Opportunity


An unusual aspect to the show is that three live audience members are invited to the stage to compete in the spelling bee alongside the six young characters. No acting experience necessary!

Please email btcspellingbee@gmail.com if you are interested!

Brewster Theater Company is Sponsored By

Please scroll down to purchase tickets

Tickets are $30 each.  ​

Performance Dates

Feb 21, 22, 23

Feb 28, Mar 1, 2

Mar 7, 8

Tickets are non-refundable. In the event you cannot make the show you may use them for another show for up to one year depending on show availability. Email BrewsterTheaterInfo@gmail.com within 10 days after the show date to establish a future credit.


Directed by Judy Brewster

Musical Director Joy Giuseffi

Produced by Stacey Cohen


The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Cast


C.J. Umbrino (Rona Lisa Perretti/Olive's Mom)
Bob Roda (Vice Principal Douglas Panch)
Nick Nazario (Chip Tolentino)
Ralph Barone Jr. (William Barfee)
Izzy Porter (Leaf Coneybear)
Em Lubbers (Olive Ostrovsky)
Rachel McNamara (Marcy Park)
Jaelyn Pollock (Logainne Schwarzandgrubenniere)
Tanya Wills (Marge Mahoney)
Nicole Vosk (Leaf's Mom,Ensemble)
Laureen Claire (Leaf's Sister,Ensemble)
Oran Matheson (Carl Dad, Jesus, Leaf's Brother, Ensemble)
Ben Bisogno (Olive's Dad, Dan dad, Leaf's Dad, Ensemble)